Jiwan Lee, Margot Jackson, Taryn Morrissey, Christopher Wimer
Sociological Science November 19, 2026
10.15195/v13.a53
Abstract
Material hardship is widespread among American families with children, disproportionately concentrated among those with the lowest incomes, and consequential for children’s long-term development. However, existing research overwhelmingly evaluates public programs in isolation and focuses on income or poverty as outcomes, leaving it unclear whether the combined resource environment that states create for families reduces disparities in hardship. Linking comprehensive state-level spending data—encompassing means-tested programs, tax credits, and universal investments including K-12 education, parks, and libraries—to household-level data from the Survey of Income and Program Participation (SIPP), we examine the association between public investments in children and material hardship from 2013 to 2019. Higher child-related spending is associated with meaningful reductions in food insecurity, housing hardship, and utility hardship, with larger reductions among households below the poverty line. A $7,400 increase in annual spending per child (1 SD) is associated with decreases of 3.0 percentage points in food, 3.7 in housing, and 4.4 in utility hardship among the poorest families. Comparing the 5th and 95th percentiles of observed state-year spending ($22,200 and $47,000 per child), predicted hardship among the poorest families is roughly 40 to 75 percent lower at the higher level, depending on the type of hardship. These findings underscore the growing importance of state-level investment in children amid a shifting federal policy landscape.
Material hardship is widespread among American families with children, disproportionately concentrated among those with the lowest incomes, and consequential for children’s long-term development. However, existing research overwhelmingly evaluates public programs in isolation and focuses on income or poverty as outcomes, leaving it unclear whether the combined resource environment that states create for families reduces disparities in hardship. Linking comprehensive state-level spending data—encompassing means-tested programs, tax credits, and universal investments including K-12 education, parks, and libraries—to household-level data from the Survey of Income and Program Participation (SIPP), we examine the association between public investments in children and material hardship from 2013 to 2019. Higher child-related spending is associated with meaningful reductions in food insecurity, housing hardship, and utility hardship, with larger reductions among households below the poverty line. A $7,400 increase in annual spending per child (1 SD) is associated with decreases of 3.0 percentage points in food, 3.7 in housing, and 4.4 in utility hardship among the poorest families. Comparing the 5th and 95th percentiles of observed state-year spending ($22,200 and $47,000 per child), predicted hardship among the poorest families is roughly 40 to 75 percent lower at the higher level, depending on the type of hardship. These findings underscore the growing importance of state-level investment in children amid a shifting federal policy landscape.
![]() | This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. |
Supplemental Materials
Reproducibility Package: The full replication package, including the STATA code used to construct the Supplemental Poverty Measure in the Survey of Income and Program Participation and to produce all tables and figures, is available at https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/H2GCDM.
- Citation: Lee, Jiwan, Margot Jackson, Taryn Morrissey, and Christopher Wimer. 2026. “State-Level Investments in Children and Disparities in Material Hardship” Sociological Science 13: 1404-1430.
- Received: June 2, 2026
- Accepted: September 24, 2026
- Editors: Stephen Vaisey, Sara Wakefield
- DOI: 10.15195/v13.a53


